Is It Cake?

It is the internet's favorite existential crisis turned game show. Hosted by the manic Mikey Day, Is It Cake? forces celebrity judges—and viewers at home—to question their own reality. Is that a bowling ball or a confectionery masterpiece? The premise is deceptively simple, but the execution requires a level of culinary deception that borders on sorcery. Following a mind-bending season finale, fans are currently stuck in a sugar-crash limbo, enduring the agonizing wait for Netflix to slice open the truth about a renewal. Until the streaming giant decides whether to serve up another round of edible illusions, adding this series to your watchlist is the only way to ensure you aren't left holding a decoy when the next cut happens.