Adapted from the hit Audible podcast, this series proves Sarah Drew can balance holiday cheer with a hidden, dangerous past.
Series Analysis:
Mistletoe Murders trades the usual sugar-cookie sweetness of the network for a sharper, pine-scented edge. Sarah Drew’s Emily Lane might run a year-round Christmas shop, but her past is far less festive than her inventory. The debut season wrapped up with a cliffhanger that left fans desperate for answers, balancing cozy romance with legitimate stakes. Currently, the series sits in that uncomfortable limbo, with viewers enduring the agonizing wait for a green light on a second chapter. Will Emily’s secrets finally catch up to her, or will she continue to outsmart the local constabulary? Investigating the status of this holiday whodunit is the only way to ensure you catch the next clue, so setting a reminder for the renewal news is your best defense against being left out in the cold.
Tone: Festive, Suspenseful, Witty
Last Updated: November 2025